*Churchill - Decisions with Death Consequences
Published by Campbell M Gold in Revisionist · Friday 23 Feb 2024
Tags: Churchill, Decisions, Death, Consequences, Winston, Churchill, Decisions, Deaths, 3.7, million, Blog, Post
Tags: Churchill, Decisions, Death, Consequences, Winston, Churchill, Decisions, Deaths, 3.7, million, Blog, Post
Churchill Decisions with Death Consequences (approx. 3,721,683 deaths).
This material, filled with sensitive and controversial content, is presented here not to influence your opinions but to ignite your academic curiosity. The information and interpretations herein do not reflect any opinion of this editor or our clients. Instead, they invite you to delve into a contentious but crucial re-evaluation.
Did Winston Churchill make any decisions with death consequences? Yes: approx. 3,721,683 deaths...
For balance, visit winstonchurchill.org
1. The Broad Fourteens Disaster, also known as the Action of 22 Sep 1914, was a major WWI naval disaster. On that day, the German submarine U-9, commanded by Otto Weddigen, sank three British cruisers in the southern North Sea: HMS Aboukir, HMS Hogue, and HMS Cressy of the 7th Cruiser Squadron.
The tragedy led to the loss of 1,459 British sailors.
The Broad Fourteens Disaster significantly impacted public confidence in the Royal Navy and resulted in changes to naval tactics, particularly concerning the vulnerability of large ships to submarine attacks.
At the time, Winston Churchill, the First Lord of the Admiralty (1911–1915), faced intense scrutiny of his leadership, proficiency, and decisions. The incident caused a significant blow to public confidence in the Royal Navy and raised questions in Parliament about the Admiralty's, particularly Churchill's, "competence", "leadership ability", and "military strategy".
As the leader of the Royal Navy, Churchill bore the ultimate responsibility for naval strategy and operations. The sinking of three British cruisers by a single German submarine underscored severe vulnerabilities in the Royal Navy's tactics and preparedness.
2. During WWI (1914-1918), Churchill played a crucial role in implementing the illegal Blockade of Germany, which resulted in the deaths of 750,000 German civilians from hunger and malnutrition. The surviving youth from this crisis went on to become fervent Nazis.
3. Churchill’s involvement in the Gallipoli Campaign during WWI resulted in approximately 46,000 Allied troops and about 65,000 Turkish troops being killed, bringing a total death count to around 111,000. The Gallipoli Campaign is often called a "significant military blunder." The campaign, from 19 Feb 1915 to 09 Jan 1916, was an attempt by the Allied Powers, primarily Britain and France, to force a naval passage through the Dardanelles Strait and capture Constantinople. At the time Churchill was the First Lord of the Admiralty (1911–1915).
4. Churchill's involvement in the Norway Campaign, which occurred from Apr to Jun 1940 during WWII, resulted in significant casualties:
- German casualties: approximately 5,296, including 1,317 killed on land and 2,375 lost at sea.
- British casualties: around 2,000 killed or wounded.
- Norwegian casualties: about 1,700, with 860 killed.
- French and Polish casualties: 533 killed, wounded, or missing.
- Norwegian civilian casualties: 535 killed.
- Total: about 10,064 casualties.
At the time, Churchill was the British Prime Minister (1940 to 1945).
5. During WWII, Churchill promoted extensive Bombing Campaigns targeting German cities/civilians. This included the bombing of Dresden, resulting in tens of thousands of civilian casualties. The overall civilian bombing campaign led to approximately 600,000 deaths. At the time, Churchill was the British Prime Minister.
6. Churchill was the final decision-maker in the Bengal Famine of 1943. As a result, around 3 million people died.
The Bengal Famine of 1943 was a devastating event in British India, leading to the deaths of an estimated 3 million people due to starvation, malnutrition, and disease. The role of Winston Churchill, the British Prime Minister at the time (1940 to 1945), has been the subject of significant criticism and heated debate.
Critics argue that Churchill's policies exacerbated the famine. For example, he refused to divert food supplies to India, prioritising the war effort in Europe and other regions. Additionally, some researchers suggest that his decisions were influenced by a belief that the famine was due to "local mismanagement" rather than a genuine "food shortage".
Conversely, some researchers argue that multiple factors, including wartime disruptions, inflation, and poor local administration, caused the famine. They contend that placing the blame solely on Churchill is overly simplistic. The debate continues.
These events above highlight the significant loss of life, some 4,471,683 people, associated with Churchill’s decisions and positional competence.
Other Examples
Other examples of Churchill's heavy-handed, questionable decision-making include:
- Views on Race and Empire: Churchill held views that are now widely considered racist and imperialist. He made several statements that reflected a belief in the superiority of the British Empire and Western civilisation, which have been criticised for their insensitivity and prejudice.
- Handling of Strikes and Protests: As Home Secretary, Churchill’s response to strikes and protests, such as the Tonypandy riots in 1910, involved deploying troops, which led to accusations of heavy-handedness and exacerbating tensions.
- Irish Independence: Churchill’s role in the suppression of the Irish War of Independence and his support for the use of force against Irish nationalists have also been points of contention.
- Post-War Policies: After WWII, Churchill’s opposition to Indian independence and his comments about Mahatma Gandhi have been criticised. His policies and attitudes towards colonies and their push for independence were often seen as outdated and oppressive.
For balance, visit winstonchurchill.org
Source:
There are no reviews yet.